Do allergies serve a purpose? 

Why do we have allergic reactions? What use do allergies serve? I can't imagine any Darwinian advantage. I can't see being a successful mastodon hunter with sneezing giving away your position. - Sneezy

Allergies are an overzealous version of the chain of events that enables your body to defend itself against foreign invaders such as parasites, protozoans, bacteria, and viruses.

Thinking it's under attack, a type of white blood cell in your body produces immunoglobulin E (IgE) antibodies. These antibodies latch onto other cells and encourage them to release histamine and other inflammatory chemicals, a hyperallergenic response sometimes called atopy.

Result: the usual allergic symptoms and a rush for the Benadryl.

Inconvenient? Sure. But what would you rather do, be a doormat for bacteria or sneeze?

About one in five people in the developed world suffers from at least one allergy. Lucky is the sufferer who's allergic to just one thing.

For example, sensitivity to ragweed or birch pollen can induce food allergies due to cross-reactions between the pollen and similar food proteins such as those found in apples.

Why are some people oversensitive? Because, to put the most positive spin on it, they're better at recognizing tiny amounts of potentially harmful substances and mobilizing a white blood cell smackdown. This process has developed over millions of years and works well overall, leading some researchers to term our immune system-even in hyperactive mode-one of the greatest success stories ofevolution.

The problem is that it takes your immune system a while to learn what's harmful and what's not, mainly by being exposed to enough of the benign substance over time. That's how allergy shots work: giving you gradually larger amounts of allergens to desensitize you.

This takes us to the so-called hygiene hypothesis, discussed here in the past. In our sterile modern world, exposure to allergens when young, a critical time for training the immune system, has been greatly reduced. Fewer chronic infections and parasites have also limited our ability to adapt to allergens.

Many studies indicate spending time on a farm during childhood reduces the likelihood of allergies, especially hanging around farm animals and stables. Drinking unprocessed milk may help.

For nonfarmers there seems to be a relationship between allergy incidence and the cleanliness of your living conditions. A German study found children who slept on dirty-sometimes filthy-mattresses were much less likely to suffer from hay fever and allergies, a protective effect seen in both farming and nonfarming households.

Children and mothers living in the less industrialized Russian part of the northern European region of Karelia had substantially fewer allergies than their more westernized Karelian neighbors in Finland. One multi-country European study found that microbial exposure while in the womb could help prevent development of allergies.

Chinese researchers found urban children were more than three times as likely to have asthma or allergies than rural kids, especially those exposed to livestock or farming. This is true even after accounting for the possibility of "healthy farmer effect"-i.e., the tendency for those who are too allergic for farm life to leave while sturdier folks remain. Urban Chinese children were almost nine times more likely to be allergic to cats than their rural cousins.

A study comparing Jewish kids in Israel and the UK found a clear inverse relationship between early peanut consumption and occurrence of peanut allergies, even after genetics and socioeconomic considerations were factored out.

Though we can't yet say why with certainty, it seems evident allergies are on the rise in the industrialized world. Long-term studies in Denmark, the UK, Japan, and other countries have found significant increases in allergy complaints.

One bright spot: allergies in France may be leveling off. Is it exposure to earthy French cuisine? No idea, but in an age of helicopter parenting, it's tempting to think the best defense against allergies may be early-childhood contact with good old-fashioned dirt.





About The Author

Cecil Adams


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Connect Today 01.16.2018

Latest in The Straight Dope

  • Do black dogs experience prejudice?
  • Do black dogs experience prejudice?

    In a 2016 article, the ASPCA looked at shelter records for nearly 300,000 dogs and cats in 14 communities. Again, the black dogs did better than the general population.
    • Jan 10, 2018
  • Do all animals yawn and stretch?
  • Do all animals yawn and stretch?

    As a scholar of yawning, the French physician Olivier Walusinski, has put it, 'its survival without any notable evolutionary variations is an indication of its functional importance.'
    • Jan 3, 2018
  • What's the connection between outlaw bikers and ball-peen hammers?
  • What's the connection between outlaw bikers and ball-peen hammers?

    Hunter S. Thompson's 1966 book on the Hells Angels doesn't mention hammers, but a later memoir by group leader Sonny Barger recalled punishment he'd visited on some guys who tried to steal his bike: 'We bullwhipped them and beat them with spiked dog collars, broke their fingers with ball-peen hammers.'
    • Dec 27, 2017
  • More »

The Most: Read | Shared | Comments

Right Now On: Twitter | Facebook

Copyright © 2018, Connect Savannah. All Rights Reserved.
Website powered by Foundation